In 2005 the Selection Committee voted for five players, and the four players receiving the most votes were inducted. The selection procedure was changed several times. They will be eligible again if they score 4 Pro Tour Points during a specific period (roughly the same period between two consecutive votings).

If a player received 10% or less of the votes in 3 consecutive votings, they will be removed from the Hall of Fame ballot. If nobody gets 60% of the vote, the player with the most votes will be inducted into the Hall of Fame. Afterwards every player with at least 60% of the votes gets inducted into the Hall of Fame. Every member of the Selection Committee gets to vote for up to five of the eligible players. The committee includes Wizards of the Coast employees, DCI members, judges, long-time reporters, developers, all Hall of Famers, and every Magic player with at least 150 Pro Points. The Selection Committee votes on whom to induct into the Hall of Fame. (* Pro Tour includes all Magic: The Gathering World Championship before year 2011) If they are currently removed by the ballot, they must finish with at least 4 Pro Points in period between the previous and current voting. The player must not currently be removed from ballot by the voting committee.The player must not currently be suspended from playing Magic or be under investigation by the DCI (Previous suspension does not disqualify a player from entering the Hall of Fame.).The player must have at least 2 single-elimination round finishes in Pro Tours.(Prior to 2013, the threshold was 100 lifetime Pro Tour Points.) The player must have at least 150 lifetime Pro Tour Points.The player must have participated in their first Magic: the Gathering Pro Tour at least 10 seasons prior to the current voting year.In order to appear on the Hall of Fame selection ballot, a player must meet the following five requirements (or the first four requirements if they never appeared in any previous ballots):

Hall of fame forge of empires wiki